Reading The Dream Keepers by Gloria Ladson-Billings helped me understand a
little more about race and culture in the classroom. I was and am committing
one of the downfalls that Ladson-Billings points out that many teachers do. On
pages 34-35 she points out how teachers make the statement “I don’t really see
color” and “I don’t care if they’re red, green, or polka dot I just treat them
like children.” I always thought that this was a good way to go about it; just
treat all of my children the same way. This might not be the right way to
approach teaching or a classroom. The fact of the matter is that these children
are different and not just different based on color. We cannot just look at all
of our students the same because let’s face it all of our students are NOT the
same. Some are going to come with learning challenges; others will come from
challenges at home. It is truly our job to be able to recognize these
differences from student to student, be able to accept them and be able to
adapt our teaching to reach each student.
I think that the teachers in the
book demonstrate teaching wonderfully because they all involve a sense of
community and holding students to high-standards in the classroom and in life. Ms.
Dupree dressed well every day because she believed she was working with the
most important people in the world (pg. 38). What a confidence boost it must
have been to those children to have a teacher say that each student was the
most important person in the world. Another teacher Ms. Devereaux points out
that “you’ve got to get a good education because the community needs your brain
power.” (pg. 43). Not only is the teacher pushing the students to excellence
but she is telling them that it is essential to give back your gifts to the
community to help the community grow and thrive. Ms. Devereaux also created a
parent phone chain that allows parents to contact each other if there is
something going on. The book shows an example of a parent’s concern for her son
being missing and the parents call around to find out where the boy is. The
teacher can not only get in touch with parents quickly but she clearly has
their trust and that goes a long way.
Something else that I wanted to
point out was a quote that I highlighted on page 13. It says “[m]y father often
worked two jobs, yet we still lived more modestly that most of my classmates
did.” It disgusts me when some people argue that black people are lazy and they
are kept in a “circle of poverty” because they do not work hard enough to get
out of it and do better for their families. If they are raised in an
educational system that is deprived they are less likely to go to college and get
well paying jobs. Now laws have changed so employers cannot discriminate based
on race but I am sure some companies still find ways to do that. Not too long ago
a white person and black person could hold the same exact position and the
white person would make more money. No wonder the black family had to work two
jobs and still made less than the white family. How can we point fingers and
blame people for being lazy when they have been put into a situation where
there is no positive outcome or no outcome that builds them up as people? Like
this book points out, there needs to be a stronger sense of community in the
classroom and link that sense in the classroom to the greater community.
I am not quite done with the book yet, but I am enjoying the reading and the different, but effective, styles of the teachers highlighted. Your first comment parallels what I have been thinking lately. As we read in an earlier book, it is not enough to be 'colorblind,' we need to see all our students differences and bring that into the classroom. Students sharing their knowledge and experiences is what will make them feel valued, develop and strengthen the connectedness in the classroom, and make their learning experiences relate to them and their lives.
ReplyDeleteI realize this study was based on African-American children, but I see this culturally relevant teaching (and learning) applying to our teaching and learning in all our classrooms.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI too initially felt I might have been guilty of the same downfall you mentioned. However, I feel that I will be very careful about judgment of a person based on that statement. In the case mentioned in the book, I completely agree. The distinction I would make and encourage others to search for is in the reason and/depth of the "not seeing color". If you are looking at each student as an individual and working with the individual and their particular culture/heritage, I would argue very highly that "seeing" color will not matter. You are already immersed in a "rainbow" of depths where color is simply a shade. If however, you are taking the statement literally and treating all the same, you do become color-blind (emphasis on blind). This is partially supported by the fact that three of the teachers were "white" but were identified as having a "bicultural orientation." (p. 32)
ReplyDeleteI encourage giving the benefit of the doubt to people who say "they do not see color" as they may be looking at a much broader spectrum of colors then just skin. Though I do feel it a worthy topic to explore and find out just what was meant with that person's particular statement as it would put them at the extremes of either "blindness" or extraordinary vision.
Ms. Dupree dressed well every day because she believed she was working with the most important people in the world (pg. 38). This quote struck me while reading the book to Kim. It's extremely powerful and it is an amazing display of care. I can only hope that , as an educator, I can project such enthusiasm. Something that stuck most of all from this book was homelife. Skin color and stereotypes are one thing, but everyone has a unique homelife. Different problems, lifestyles, fights, brothers and sisters, languages, etc are all brought into the classroom each day. Such diversity can seem overwhelming to a teacher, however making the content relatable to the students will make learning worth it. Letting a student know that they're not just another black kid, but rather have a name an a story that matters, truly will make the difference.
ReplyDeleteKim and Phil, that quote speaks volumes to Ms Dupree's character. Not only does it mean so much to adults to read that and realize just how important it is, but saying things like that to students, and genuinely meaning it, can really make a huge difference. Minority students have often been marginalized, not necessarily in school but also in society. To hear that an adult, even just one, respects them and sees them as important can really turn things around for students.
ReplyDelete